Disclosure: This post for The Best Easter Egg Fillers contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

This Easter, up your egg hunt game with egg fillers that go beyond the ordinary! Our guide to Easter Egg Fillers is here to make the holiday festivities not only easier but add a dose of excitement into your Easter eggstravaganza. 

Scroll down for the complete list The Best Easter Egg Fillers or PIN IT for later!

There isn’t a holiday that comes and goes that doesn’t fill us with joy and excitement and Easter is no exception! 

We love that Easter symbolizes the welcome of spring with warmer weather, fresh spring produce, Easter egg hunts and cute bunny themed Easter baskets filled with fun surprises and treats.

While we are not opposed to filling Easter eggs with our favorite fruit flavored candies and chocolates, it’s fun to throw in a few other non-candy Easter egg fillers and goodies to change things up and balance things out.

From whimsical toys to delectable treats and colorful art supplies, we are sharing our best ideas for some candy free Easter Egg Fillers that will have everyone hopping with delight.

Non-Candy Easter Egg Fillers

Many of these fillers for Easter eggs can be found at the dollar store, in the Target dollar spot or online. We also like to check out the party supply section of stores as many party favor toys, like mini stamps or rubber bouncy balls, make great Easter egg fillers.

You can also purchase pre-filled Easter eggs, but we prefer to pick up individual items, that we stuff in the eggs ourselves, that way we can pick the items that are best for our family.

In addition to filling plastic eggs with fun treats, you could also hide egg shaped toys, like egg shaped crayons or the eggs to this matching game. 

Below we have broken up our guide to fillers for Easter eggs by type and have included ideas for Easter egg fillers for toddlers, adults, teens and kids!

One important note is the size of plastic Easter eggs can vary greatly, so something like a toy car or mini rubber ducky may need to go in larger eggs, whereas a few cheddar crackers can go in the smaller eggs.

From the usual suspects, like chocolate candies, to non-candy Easter egg fillers – our egg filler ideas not only promise smiles, but also ensure that your Easter egg hunt is like no other. Because why settle for ordinary when you can have eggstraordinary?

Easter Egg Fillers for Toddlers

Note: Some items listed below are NOT toddler or baby friendly and could pose a choking hazard. Please use caution and follow the recommendations of your health care provider.

Food:

1. Chocolate candy
2. Non chocolate candy (Jolly Ranchers, Starbursts, etc.)
3. Fruit snacks
4. Dried fruit
5. Mini raisin boxes
6. Chocolate covered fruit
7. Gerber puffs
8. Cereal
9. Gum
10. Mints
11. Mini granola bars
12. Mini fruit bars
13. Individual packets of nuts or trail mix
14. Mini packs of cookies or crackers
15. Popcorn
16. Pretzels
17. Water flavoring drink mix packets
18. Hot cocoa packets
19. Crackers (goldfish, teddy grahams, etc.) – Individually wrapped packages or single crackers
20. Mini Rice Krispie Treats
21. Tea bags Toys and Games:
22. Alphabet magnets 
23. Puzzle pieces (put a few in each egg and then have the puzzle box in the Easter basket)
24. Counting bears  
25. Mini character figurines
26. Legos
27. Lego figurines
28. Toy cars
29. Hacky sack
30. Hatching dinosaur eggs  
31. Playdough
32. Mini animal figurines
33. Mini rubber duckies
34. Mini bubbles
35. Mini squishes
36. Finger puppets  
37. Bouncy balls
38. Mini stuffed animals
39. The eggs from this matching egg shape game  
40. Mini pop it’s
41. Army men
42. Doll clothes
43. Whistles
44. Regular dice
45. Story dice  
46. Silly putty
47. Jax
48. Marbles
49. Toy bugs  
50. Color changing bugs   Bath, Beauty and Hair Products:
51. Hair ties
52. Barrettes
53. Scrunchies 
54. Lip gloss
55. Chapstick
56. Temporary tattoos
57. Nail polish (this is our favorite brand of kid safe nail polish)
58. Makeup
59. Floss sticks
60. Regular box of floss
61. Travel sized toothpaste
62. Travel sized lotion
63. Mini bottle hand sanitizer
64. Pocket sized pack of tissues
65. Beauty face mask
66. Band aids
67. Easter egg bath bombs  
    
     Jewelry and Accessories:
68. Rings
69. Bracelets
70. Necklaces
71. Slap bracelets
72. Earrings – Real, clip on and sticker
73. Shoe charms for crocs  
74. Shoelaces
75. Socks 
    
    Money and Gift Certificates:
76. Money – coins and dollar bills
77. Coupons for fun activities or privileges
78. Scavenger hunt clues to find Easter basket
79. Coins that work for a local arcade
80. Gift certificates to local businesses Craft and Art Supplies:
81. Stickers
82. Mini stamps
83. Erasers
84. Washi tape
85. Easter egg shaped crayons 
86. Post it notes
87. Pencil grips 
88. Egg shaped chalk 
89. Mini ceramic figures to paint
90. Mini paint
91. Mini wooden figures/shapes to paint 
92. Charms to make necklaces
93. Beads
94. Craft Pom Poms
    
    Other:
95. Magic towels
96. Kinder joy eggs
97. Key chains
98. Cool rocks or gems
99. Egg shaped candles
100. Cell phone pop socket
101. Glow in the dark stars
102. Egg shakers 

For more recipes, cooking tips and behind the scenes fun, subscribe to our newsletter or follow Kitchen Concoctions on Instagram, Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest!

Looking for more Easter recipes and crafts, check out these ideas below:

• Change up an Easter tradition and make these fun Whipped Cream Dyed Easter Eggs! 
• Got leftover dyed Easter eggs or chocolate Easter candy? Then make these soft Hard Boiled Egg Chocolate Chip Cookies! 
• Easter will be here before you know it and here is a fun Easter dessert to help welcome spring! Check out our recipe Chocolate Bird’s Nest Donuts using our favorite chocolate Easter candies, a modern twist on those popular Bird’s Nest Cookies!